I think it probably needs another day to ripen then I will eat it and update.
if you try to give him something he just doubles down and brings you even more shit the next time in an exponential way. I gave him some chocolate once and he kept bringing me avocados, like more than I could possibly eat before they get overripe, but he saw me eating an avocado for lunch once and figured that I must love avacados so he bought a bunch to give to me